When you’re shopping for outdoor furniture, two names almost always come up: LuxCraft and Polywood. Both are leaders in the world of poly lumber furniture, known for their eco-friendly materials, timeless styles, and long-lasting durability.
But the question remains: Which brand should you choose for your porch, patio, or backyard? Let’s break down how LuxCraft and Polywood compare when it comes to design, comfort, strength, warranty, and price—so you can decide which one is the right investment for your outdoor space.
What Makes Poly Lumber Furniture Special?
Before diving into brand comparisons, it’s worth understanding what makes poly lumber such a popular choice. Made from recycled HDPE plastics (think milk jugs and detergent bottles), poly lumber is molded into boards that look like real wood but perform far better outdoors.
Unlike traditional wood furniture, poly lumber won’t rot, crack, or splinter. It doesn’t need to be stained or sealed, and the color runs through the material so scratches are barely noticeable. This makes it one of the best options for weatherproof patio furniture.
Both LuxCraft outdoor furniture and Polywood furniture use this same material, but the way they build, design, and warranty their products sets them apart.
Why Choose LuxCraft?
If you’re looking for premium craftsmanship, LuxCraft is a name that stands out. Each piece is made in the USA by skilled Amish builders, giving it a reputation for strength and attention to detail. LuxCraft is known for using extra-thick poly lumber boards, which make their products heavier, sturdier, and less likely to tip or blow away in windy conditions.
Their designs lean toward classic outdoor styles—you’ll find plenty of Adirondack chairs, poly gliders, porch swings, and picnic tables that look timeless in any setting. LuxCraft also offers two-tone color options, so you can mix and match shades for a custom look.
Another major advantage is LuxCraft’s lifetime residential warranty, which shows just how confident they are in the durability of their furniture.
Highlights of LuxCraft:
-
Extra-thick boards for superior strength
-
Heavy and stable, even in strong winds
-
Lifetime warranty for residential buyers
-
Classic Amish craftsmanship
- Wide selection of rocking outdoor chair, swings, and dining sets
Why Choose Polywood?
Polywood has been around since the early 1990s and is often seen as the brand that started the poly lumber furniture trend. Their products are also made in the USA and use the same recycled HDPE plastic, but Polywood tends to offer a wider variety of styles and price points.
Unlike LuxCraft, Polywood’s furniture is generally lighter, making it easier to move around your deck, patio, or poolside. While the boards aren’t as thick as LuxCraft’s, they’re still extremely durable and hold up well in all weather conditions.
Polywood is also known for offering 20-year residential warranties, which is still excellent compared to most outdoor furniture brands.
If style matters to you, Polywood may be the better choice. They carry everything from traditional adirondack glider chairs to sleek, modern lounge sets. Their color palette is also broad, so you’ll find plenty of options to match your outdoor décor.
Highlights of Polywood:
-
Trusted pioneer in recycled plastic furniture
-
20-year residential warranty
-
Lightweight and easy to move
-
Wide variety of modern and traditional styles
- Usually more affordable than LuxCraft
Durability and Weather Resistance
Both LuxCraft and Polywood are built to handle the elements. Their HDPE poly lumber is resistant to UV rays, fading, moisture, and mildew. Whether you live in a hot, sunny climate or an area with snow and rain, both brands are designed to last for decades without splintering or cracking.
That said, LuxCraft has an edge when it comes to heavier-duty builds. Their thicker materials and heavier weight make them ideal for coastal areas or windy regions. Polywood, while durable, is easier to move around but may not feel as substantial in storm-prone locations.
Comfort and Design
When you sit down in either brand’s chairs, you’ll notice thoughtful design. LuxCraft tends to focus on comfort-first builds with deep seats, wide arms, and contoured backs that encourage hours of relaxation. Their Adirondack gliders and swings are especially popular for those who love the soothing motion of rocking.
Polywood, meanwhile, shines with its versatility in design. If you want a modern, streamlined look for your patio, Polywood has collections that LuxCraft doesn’t. They also have a wide range of rocking chairs, loungers, and modular deep-seating sets perfect for entertaining.
Warranty and Long-Term Value
Warranty is often what seals the deal for many buyers. LuxCraft’s lifetime warranty is hard to beat and ensures you’ll never need to replace your furniture again. Polywood’s 20-year warranty is also strong and offers peace of mind for long-term durability.
If you’re investing for the long haul and don’t mind paying more upfront, LuxCraft is the clear winner. If you want a reliable product that’s slightly easier on the budget, Polywood is still a fantastic choice.
Price Comparison
Polywood is generally more budget-friendly, making it a great entry point into poly outdoor furniture. LuxCraft is a bit more expensive, but you’re paying for heavier builds, handcrafted details, and that lifetime warranty.
Think of it this way: Polywood is great if you’re furnishing a large outdoor area and want stylish, lightweight furniture at a fair price. LuxCraft is ideal if you want heirloom-quality outdoor pieces that will last a lifetime.
Which Brand is Right for You?
So, should you buy LuxCraft or Polywood? The answer depends on your needs:
-
Choose LuxCraft if you value premium quality, Amish craftsmanship, heavier furniture, and a lifetime warranty.
- Choose Polywood if you prefer lighter, easier-to-move furniture, more color choices, and slightly lower prices.
Either way, you’re getting eco-friendly, low-maintenance furniture that’s built to last decades.
Final Thoughts
Both LuxCraft and Polywood make exceptional poly lumber furniture. Your choice really comes down to whether you prefer the classic, heavy-duty design of LuxCraft or the versatile, widely available style of Polywood.
If you’re ready to upgrade your outdoor space, explore our full collection of LuxCraft furniture along with timeless Adirondack rocking chairs, relaxing outdoor rocking chairs, and smooth poly adirondack glider chair to find the perfect fit for your home.
FAQs
1. Is LuxCraft better than Polywood for outdoor furniture?
Both brands are excellent, but LuxCraft is often considered the premium choice. It uses thicker, heavier boards, offers a lifetime warranty, and features Amish craftsmanship. Polywood, however, is more affordable and versatile in style, making it a strong option for those who want lighter, stylish outdoor furniture.
2. How long does Polywood outdoor furniture last?
Polywood furniture is designed to last for decades. With its 20-year residential warranty, you can expect Polywood Adirondack chairs, rockers, and dining sets to withstand harsh weather, including sun, rain, and snow, without cracking or fading.
3. What makes LuxCraft outdoor furniture different?
LuxCraft is known for Amish craftsmanship and using thicker HDPE poly lumber, which makes its furniture heavier, more stable, and ideal for windy or coastal areas. The lifetime residential warranty is another standout feature, ensuring your investment truly lasts.
4. Is poly lumber furniture eco-friendly?
Yes! Both LuxCraft and Polywood make their products from recycled HDPE plastics, such as milk jugs and containers. This process keeps plastic waste out of landfills and oceans, making poly lumber furniture a sustainable and eco-friendly option for outdoor living.
5. Which brand is more affordable: LuxCraft or Polywood?
Polywood is generally more budget-friendly, offering a wide range of options at accessible prices. LuxCraft costs more upfront, but its lifetime warranty and premium build quality make it a worthwhile long-term investment.
